The LA Dodgers Claim the World Series, But for Hispanic Fans, It's Not So Simple
For a lifelong Dodgers fan and third-generation Mexican American, the most memorable moment of the World Series did not happen during the tense final game on Saturday, when her squad pulled off one dramatic comeback feat after another before prevailing in overtime over the Toronto Blue Jays.
It came in the previous game, when two second-tier players, Kike Hernández and Miguel Rojas, pulled off a electrifying, decisive sequence that at the same time upended many harmful misconceptions touted about Hispanic people in recent years.
The play itself was breathtaking: Hernández charged in from left field to catch a ball he at first lost in the bright lights, then fired it to the infield to secure another, game-winning play. the second baseman, positioned nearby, caught the ball moments before a runner collided with him, knocking him to the ground.
This wasn't merely a remarkable sporting achievement, perhaps the decisive shift in momentum in the team's direction after appearing for most of the series like the weaker side. For Molina, it was thrilling, politically and culturally, a much-required morale boost for Latinos and for Los Angeles after months of enforcement actions, troops patrolling the neighborhoods, and a constant drumbeat of negativity from official sources.
"Kike and Miggy presented this alternative story," said Molina. "Everyone witnessed Latinos displaying an infectious pride and joy in what they do, being leaders on the team, exhibiting a distinct kind of confidence. They're energetic, they're yelling, they're removing their shirts."
"It was such a contrast with what we observe on the news – raids, Latinos detained and pursued. It's so simple to be disheartened right now."
Not that it's entirely straightforward to be a team fan nowadays – for Molina or for the legions of other Latinos who show up regularly to matches and fill up as many as half of the venue's 50,000 seats each time.
The Mixed Connection with the Organization
When aggressive enforcement operations started in Los Angeles in June, and military units were sent into the area to react to ensuing protests, two of the city's sports clubs quickly issued messages of solidarity with affected communities – while the baseball team.
The team president has said the Dodgers prefer to stay away of political issues – a view colored, perhaps, by the fact that a sizable minority of the supporters, including Latinos, are supporters of certain political figures. Under considerable public pressure, the organization later pledged $1m in support for individuals directly impacted by the raids but issued no public criticism of the administration.
White House Event and Past Legacy
Months earlier, the team did not delay in agreeing to an offer to celebrate their previous World Series victory at the official residence – a decision that sports writers described as "disappointing … weak … and hypocritical", considering the team's pride in having been the first professional team to break the racial segregation in the mid-20th century and the regular invocations of that history and the values it embodies by officials and present and former athletes. A number of team members including the manager had expressed reluctance to go to the White House during the first term but either changed their minds or succumbed to demands from the organization.
Business Control and Supporter Conflicts
A further issue for supporters is that the team are owned by a large investment group, Guggenheim Partners, whose investments, as per sources and its own published balance sheets, involve a stake in a detention corporation that runs enforcement facilities. The group's leadership has said repeatedly that it wants to remain neutral of politics, but its critics say the silence – and the financial stake – are their own type of acquiescence to current agendas.
All of that contribute to significant conflicted emotions among Latino fans in especial – feelings that emerged even in the euphoria of this year's hard-fought championship victory and the following outpouring of Dodgers support across Los Angeles.
"Is it okay to support the Dodgers?" local writer Erick Galindo agonized at the beginning of the postseason in an thoughtful essay pondering on "team loyalty in our blood, but uncertainty in our minds". He was unable to ultimately bring himself to view the World Series, but he still cared strongly, to the extent that he believed his personal boycott must have brought the team the luck it required to win.
Distinguishing the Players from the Owners
Numerous supporters who share similar reservations seem to have concluded that they can continue to back the team and its lineup of international stars, including the Asian megastar a key player, while pouring scorn on the team's corporate leadership. Nowhere was this more clear than at the victory celebration at the home venue on Monday, when the packed audience roared in approval of the coach and his players but jeered the team president and the top official of the ownership group.
"These men in suits do not get to claim our players from us," the fan said. "We have been with the Dodgers longer than they have."
Past Background and Community Impact
The issue, however, goes further than only the organization's current proprietors. The agreement that moved the Brooklyn Dodgers to the city in the late 1950s involved the municipality razing three working-class Latino neighborhoods on a hill above downtown and then selling the land to the team for a small part of its market value. A song on a 2005 album that documents the events has an impoverished parking attendant at the venue stating that the home he forfeited to removal is now third base.
Gustavo Arellano, possibly the region's most widely followed Latino writer and media personality, sees a darker side to the lengthy, dysfunctional relationship between the franchise and its audience. He describes the team the popular snack of baseball, "a corporate entity with an excessive, even harmful following by numerous Latinos" that has been shortchanging its supporters for decades.
"They've acted around Latino followers while picking their pockets with the other for so long because they have been able to avoid consequences," the writer noted over the summer, when demands to boycott the team over its absence of response to the enforcement actions were contradicted by the awkward fact that attendance at matches remained steady, even at the height of the demonstrations when downtown LA was subject to a nightly restriction.
Global Players and Community Connections
Separating the team from its corporate owners is not a easy matter, {